Shelter Island Heigh, New York short-term rental listings & supply

Name: Shelter Island Heigh, New York short-term rental supply data
Creator: AirDNA
License: https://www.airdna.co/terms

Updated September 29, 2026By The AirDNA Data Team

Shelter Island Heigh, New York has 140 active short-term rental listings, tracked across Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com.

Explore Shelter Island Heigh in the app

See revenue potential of any address

Total active listings

140

+84.2% YoY

Shelter Island Heigh, New York short-term rental listings

Shelter Island Heigh has 140 active short-term rental listings as of August 2026, tracked across Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com. Active supply is up 84.2% from August 2025 to August 2026. Here's how the market breaks down:

By property type: 90% entire homes, 10% private rooms.
By size: 30% 3-bedroom, 27.6% 4-bedroom, 18.1% 5+ bedroom, 14.3% 1-bedroom, and 10% 2-bedroom.
By channel: 42.9% cross-listed, 38.1% Airbnb-only and 19% Vrbo-only.
By availability: 56.7% full-time (271–365), 17.1% most of year (181–270), 15.7% part-time (91–180 nights), and 10.5% seasonal (1–90 nights).
By minimum stay: 27.6% 7–29 nights, 25.2% 2 nights, 19% 3 nights, 14.3% 30+ nights, and 13.8% 4–6 nights.
By cancellation policy: 48.9% strict, 22.2% moderate, 18.9% flexible, 6.7% super strict, and 3.3% no refund.

Rental demand score

Rental demand45
Seasonality41
Revenue growth73
Investability47
Regulation53

Full Shelter Island Heigh market overview How Market Score is calculated

Analyst's take

Shelter Island Heigh's Rental Demand score: 45 out of 100.

Shelter Island Heigh's Rental Demand subscore is 45 out of 100, one of five inputs to its overall Market Score of 41.

Rental Demand combines two inputs: annual occupancy (46% in Shelter Island Heigh) and year-over-year listing growth (active supply up 84.2% from August 2025 to August 2026).

It is benchmarked against other short-term rental markets in the same country with at least 15 active listings.

The Market Score is a starting point, not an investment decision.

Market-level averages hide wide variation. Here's how to go deeper in the app:

1Narrow to a neighborhoodNeighborhood metrics give a far more accurate picture of the exact area you're considering.
2Apply filtersFilter by bedrooms, price tier, amenities, and reviews to reach properties that actually match yours.
3Estimate one addressProject what one specific property can earn with a custom comp set built from its exact specs.

Explore Shelter Island Heigh in the app

See revenue potential of any address

Key definitions

How AirDNA defines these metrics

Active listings: Active listings are the short-term rentals on Airbnb, Vrbo, and Booking.com that were available or booked in the trailing 12 months. AirDNA de-duplicates the same home across channels, and the count refreshes monthly.How AirDNA counts active listings →