Best Places to Buy a Lake House for Rentals in 2026
Published: November 22, 2024
Last updated: October 19, 2026
Camilo Schmid Rivas
Key Takeaways
- Lake markets deliver some strong gross yields in short-term rental investing, but the spread is tighter than headline numbers suggest. The ten markets below run from 9.1% to 13.8%.
- Local rules now decide whether a lake market is investable at all. Several lake markets in the country are closed to new permits entirely, which is why they are not on this list.
- AirDNA lets investors compare revenue, occupancy, seasonality, and home values at the submarket level, so the question stops being which lake sounds good and becomes which lake pays.
Scenic views, privacy, and steady family demand have made lake houses one of the more durable corners of the short-term rental market. A lakefront home gives travelers something a hotel cannot, and it gives owners a summer season that books itself.
What has changed since we last ran this analysis is the regulatory picture. Lake towns spent 2024 and 2025 writing short-term rental ordinances, and several of the strongest-performing lake markets in the country now cap permits or have stopped issuing them. A market can look excellent on revenue and still be impossible to enter. We screened for that before ranking anything, although you should still check the rules for any specific property.
Find the Best Places to Invest
AirDNA’s annual Best Places to Invest report ranks the top U.S. markets by revenue potential, demand, and affordability.
Start for freeBest Places to Buy a Lake House in 2026
The best places to buy a lake house for short-term rentals in 2026 are Erie, Pennsylvania; Muskegon, Michigan; Otsego Lake, Michigan; Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania; and Salisbury, North Carolina, with gross yields across the top ten running from 9.1% to 13.8%.
Using AirDNA data, we ranked lake submarkets on the Best Places to Invest score, which weighs demand, revenue growth, and the yield available on homes for sale right now. We then checked that each market is a true lake market rather than a town that happens to sit near water, and that a buyer can still get a permit.
Here are the ten that made it.

1. Erie, Pennsylvania


Erie sits on the only Great Lake shoreline Pennsylvania has, and Presque Isle State Park draws four million visitors a year to a sand spit fifteen minutes from downtown. It tops this list on the strength of one number: at a median list price of $232,500, it is by far the cheapest entry point of the ten, and cheap homes against solid revenue is what produces yield.
Be clear about what you are buying. Erie is a lakefront city rather than a lake cabin market, and only 2% of homes for sale carry a waterfront designation. The upside is year-round demand from a real local economy rather than a twelve-week season.
- Revenue potential: $32,616
- Occupancy rate: 56.1%
- Average daily rate: $169
- Yield: 11.2%
- RevPAR: $95
- Median list price: $232,500
One thing to check before you buy: Erie treats short-term rentals as a conditional use in its waterfront districts and a special exception in low-density residential zones, which means a Zoning Hearing Board decision on your specific property rather than an automatic right. Confirm your parcel before you commit.
2. Muskegon, Michigan


Muskegon holds a rare position on a neck of land with Muskegon Lake on one side and Lake Michigan on the other, and the Beachwood and Bluffton neighborhoods sit right on it. Demand is sharply seasonal, with 47% of the year’s booked nights falling in June, July, and August, and the summer rate reflects it.
At a $289,900 median list price against a $43,811 revenue estimate, Muskegon produces the second-best yield on this list while still offering real waterfront stock.
- Revenue potential: $43,811
- Occupancy rate: 54.0%
- Average daily rate: $292
- Yield: 11.4%
- RevPAR: $158
- Median list price: $289,900
3. Otsego Lake, Michigan


Northern Michigan around Gaylord gives you Otsego Lake, Lake Margrethe, and a scatter of smaller lakes, and it is the only market on this list that works in both directions. Summer is the peak, with half the year’s nights booked between June and August, but the area also carries ski and snowmobile demand that keeps winter from going dark.
This is the most rural entry in the top five, with a median list price of $285,000 keeping the yield above 11%.
- Revenue potential: $33,954
- Occupancy rate: 45.8%
- Average daily rate: $284
- Yield: 11.1%
- RevPAR: $130
- Median list price: $285,000
4. Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania


The Poconos have been renting houses to New York and Philadelphia for a century, and Tobyhanna sits in the middle of it with roughly 1,300 listings competing in the submarket. That is the deepest inventory on this list and the most professionalized operating environment.
Tobyhanna returns the highest yield of the ten at 13.8%, driven by a $387 average daily rate against a $324,000 median list price. Occupancy is the trade-off. At 40% it is the lowest here, which is what a large-home weekend market looks like: fewer nights, much higher rates.
- Revenue potential: $43,757
- Occupancy rate: 40.0%
- Average daily rate: $387
- Yield: 13.8%
- RevPAR: $155
- Median list price: $324,000
5. Salisbury, North Carolina


Salisbury is the market on this list that rewards a second look. High Rock Lake is North Carolina’s second-largest reservoir with 365 miles of shoreline, and Salisbury is the town that serves it from fifteen miles inland, with a historic downtown, a college, and Interstate 85 running through it.
That distance is the point. You are buying small-city housing at $329,950 with lake access nearby rather than a dock in the backyard, and the demand profile follows: the least seasonal market in the top five, with only 30% of nights falling in summer. For an investor who wants a lake market without a dead winter, that is a feature.
- Revenue potential: $33,940
- Occupancy rate: 54.5%
- Average daily rate: $155
- Yield: 9.3%
- RevPAR: $85
- Median list price: $329,950
6. Anderson, South Carolina


Lake Hartwell covers 56,000 acres across the Georgia and South Carolina line, and Anderson is the town that anchors its western shore. Clemson is twenty minutes away, which gives the market a football season on top of a boating season and explains why it is one of the least seasonal entries on this list, with only 27% of nights booked in summer.
Anderson is the town rather than the shoreline, and what it offers is the strongest revenue growth of the ten, with RevPAR up 9.2% year over year, against a median price of $302,500.
- Revenue potential: $32,922
- Occupancy rate: 51.6%
- Average daily rate: $147
- Yield: 9.1%
- RevPAR: $76
- Median list price: $302,500
7. Pocono Lake, Pennsylvania


If you want the purest lake house market on this list, this is it. 85% of homes for sale around Pocono Pines, Pocono Lake, and Blakeslee are marketed as lake property, the highest share of any submarket we screened. Lake Naomi and Tobyhanna Lake sit at the center of a set of private lake communities that have been renting to the same families for generations.
That quality costs money. At $464,900 the median list price is the second highest here, and the $430 average daily rate is also second highest. The result is a $50,058 revenue estimate on a large, well-equipped house, with a 9.8% yield.
- Revenue potential: $50,058
- Occupancy rate: 41.3%
- Average daily rate: $430
- Yield: 9.8%
- RevPAR: $178
- Median list price: $464,900
8. Gainesville, Georgia


Lake Lanier is the busiest Corps of Engineers lake in the country, and Gainesville is its northern hub, an hour from Atlanta. It posts the highest occupancy on this list at 57.6% and the flattest seasonal curve, with just 25% of nights falling in summer. For an investor who does not want income concentrated in twelve weeks, that combination is unusual.
- Revenue potential: $48,810
- Occupancy rate: 57.6%
- Average daily rate: $217
- Yield: 10.0%
- RevPAR: $125
- Median list price: $409,900
9. Mooresville, North Carolina


Lake Norman is the largest man-made lake in North Carolina, and Mooresville is its best-known town, half an hour from Charlotte and home to most of NASCAR’s race shops. It is the premium end of this list in every sense: the highest revenue estimate at $53,993, the highest daily rate at $552, and the highest RevPAR at $289.
It is also the most expensive, with a median list price of $569,999. The 9.3% yield is mid-pack precisely because the asset is expensive, but Lake Norman is one of the few markets here with year-round urban demand underneath the boating season.
- Revenue potential: $53,993
- Occupancy rate: 52.3%
- Average daily rate: $552
- Yield: 9.3%
- RevPAR: $289
- Median list price: $569,999
10. Manistee, Michigan


Manistee is the most physically lakefront market on this list. 30% of homes for sale carry a waterfront designation, which is more than double anywhere else here, and the submarket stacks Lake Michigan against Manistee Lake, Portage Lake at Onekama, and Bear Lake. It is also the most seasonal, with 52% of the year’s nights booked across June, July, and August.
At a $349,000 median list price against a $36,351 revenue estimate, Manistee is the affordable way to own actual water frontage on this list. The trade is a short season.
- Revenue potential: $36,351
- Occupancy rate: 52.0%
- Average daily rate: $257
- Yield: 9.2%
- RevPAR: $134
- Median list price: $349,000
What to Consider When Investing in Lakefront Property
Buying well on a lake takes more than finding a scenic spot. Four things move the return more than anything else.
Where the house sits on the lake
The yields above reflect the whole submarket. Within any of these markets, where a house sits changes everything.
A property with direct frontage and a private dock commands the highest rates and the highest price. One a few streets back with a lake view and trail access can produce a better return on capital, because the purchase price falls faster than the nightly rate does. The waterfront share in our data shows how much of this choice a market even offers: 30% of listed homes in Manistee are waterfront against 2% in Erie and Anderson. In a market with thin waterfront stock, you are competing for a small number of houses, and paying for it.
Seasonality and how it shapes cash flow
Lake demand concentrates in summer, but the degree varies more than investors expect. Across the ten markets above, the share of the year’s booked nights falling in June, July, and August runs from 25% to 52%.
Manistee sits at the seasonal extreme. Just over half its annual demand lands in three months, which means strong summer cash flow and a long quiet winter to fund. Gainesville sits at the other end at 25%, close to an even spread across the year, because Lake Lanier draws from Atlanta in every season. Otsego Lake manages something rarer, pairing a summer lake season with winter ski and snowmobile demand.
Neither profile is better. A concentrated season suits an investor who can carry the off months and wants high peak rates. A flat curve suits one who needs the property to cover its own costs every month. What matters is knowing which one you are buying before the first January.
Drive-to demand holds up when travel slows
Lake trips are planned around convenience and togetherness. Guests usually arrive by car, travel with family or friends, and stay longer, so lake markets depend less on airfare and more on space, comfort, and the water itself. That is part of why the least seasonal markets on this list, such as Gainesville and Anderson, keep booking well outside summer.
Amenities earn their cost
For a lake house, the amenity list is the product. A private dock turns a rental into a boating base. A fire pit, kayaks, paddleboards, and a hot tub are what separate a booked calendar from an empty one in shoulder season.
Large shared spaces matter more here than in city rentals, because these houses sell to families and groups. Dining space that seats a dozen, generous outdoor living, and a real view of the water do more for occupancy than another bedroom. AirDNA’s amenity filters let you compare how specific features move occupancy and rate within a given lake market, rather than guessing from national averages.
Drill Into Your Submarket
City averages hide the street-level story. Compare neighborhoods to find the pockets that outperform.
Get started
Pros and Cons of Buying a Lake House for Short-Term Rentals
Pros
- Premium rates in season. Lakefront homes draw families and groups willing to pay for something a hotel cannot offer. Average daily rates across the ten markets above run from $147 to $552, and the top of that range is set almost entirely by water access.
- Group and family demand. Lake houses suit the guest type that books longest and returns most reliably. That shows up as steadier occupancy and lower turnover cost than a comparable city rental.
- Constrained supply. Shoreline does not expand. In markets where waterfront is a small share of the housing stock, that scarcity supports both nightly rate and long-term value in a way inland stock rarely matches.
Cons
- Concentrated income. In the most seasonal markets above, half the year’s revenue arrives in three months. Carrying costs do not follow that pattern, so the off-season has to be funded from the peak.
- Higher maintenance. Water, weather, and sun are hard on exteriors, decks, and docks. Budget above what a comparable inland property would need.
- Higher insurance. Flood and storm exposure raise premiums, sometimes sharply, and coverage terms on waterfront structures are worth reading before the purchase rather than after.
- Shoreline you may not control. On federally managed reservoirs, the water’s edge belongs to the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers, and dock rights are permitted separately and do not always transfer on sale.
Methodology: How We Ranked the Best Lake Markets
This analysis answers one question: where can you buy a lake house today that is likely to perform tomorrow, and operate it legally?
Starting from homes that are for sale
We begin with residential listings currently on the market rather than with market averages, and estimate the short-term rental income each one could generate from the booking patterns, pricing, and seasonal demand of comparable active rentals nearby. We then compare that income to the list price.
That order matters. A market can look excellent on rental performance and offer nothing worth buying, either because inventory is thin or because prices have run ahead of achievable revenue. Starting from real for-sale stock keeps the list to markets where the numbers work and the houses exist.
The Best Places to Invest score
Each submarket is scored on three components.
Demand covers trailing twelve-month occupancy, the share of available nights booked, together with growth in the number of booked listings. Between them, they capture how busy a market is and whether interest is rising.
Revenue growth is the year-over-year change in RevPAR, which is average daily rate multiplied by occupancy. It reflects both pricing power and booking frequency, so it shows whether properties are becoming more profitable rather than just more numerous.
Investability is gross yield, annual revenue potential divided by list price, aggregated across the for-sale inventory in the submarket. It carries the heaviest weight because it is the component that tells an investor what their capital buys.
Identifying true lake markets
AirDNA classifies every submarket by the demand drivers behind its travel, and we started from the submarkets whose drivers include a lake. That classification is broad by design, so we tested it rather than trusting it.
For each candidate, we measured the share of homes for sale marketed as lake property, the share carrying a waterfront designation, and the share of annual booked nights falling in summer. Calibrating those three signals separates true lake markets from towns that merely sit near water, and removes places where a lake appears on the map but plays no part in why anyone books.
Screening for regulation
Every market in the final ranking was checked against the ordinances of the municipalities that govern it, which is often not the one the submarket is named after. Markets where a new buyer cannot obtain a permit were removed regardless of score. Markets with caps, conditional-use requirements, or unusual permit costs were kept. Rules can change at any time, so always confirm current regulations before you buy.
Data window
Performance metrics cover the twelve months from September 2025 through August 2026, the most recent complete year of data. For-sale inventory and prices are drawn from active listings as of September 2026. Revenue potential and list price are reported as medians for the submarket, and yield is calculated across the full for-sale set rather than as an average of individual yields.
How to Use AirDNA to Analyze Lakefront Investment Opportunities
When it comes to lakefront properties, location is everything. A house on one side of the lake might be a goldmine, while one just a few miles away struggles to make waves. AirDNA makes it easy to figure out where to cast your net for the best returns.
Shortlist lake markets with demand driver filters
If you haven’t picked a lake yet, start in the Find a Market tab. The Market filter lets you search by demand driver, so you can pull up lake markets directly and compare ones with similar demand but different prices, competition, or maturity.

With AirDNA’s Custom Draw feature, available on the Advanced tier, investors can create custom regions within a lake market to compare performance metrics for different parts of the lake, making it easier to identify prime areas for investment.
If you’re ready to purchase a lakefront property, here’s how you can use AirDNA to compare the revenue performance of houses located on different parts of the lake:
(We’ll use Lake Norman in the Mooresville, NC submarket to illustrate.)
Step 1: Search and zoom in
Begin by searching for the submarket in the AirDNA search bar. This will pull up an overview page with performance metrics for the entire submarket. At the top, you’ll see annual revenue, occupancy, ADR, and RevPAR for all properties in the area. Scroll down to explore historical data for each metric, which will help you understand recent performance.
Step 2: Expand and customize the map
Select the black arrow on the map to expand the view of the submarket.

From here, you can see all active STR listings over the past year, plus any lakefront properties currently for sale. Use the plus and minus signs on the map to zoom in on specific areas.

Step 3: Draw custom regions
To create your first custom region, select the draw button in the bottom right-hand corner of the map, then outline an area of interest by clicking and dragging on the map.
For example, if you’re looking to buy on Lake Norman, you might draw a polygon around properties near Doolie, an area of Lake Norman with strong rental demand. When you close the polygon, the custom region you’ve created will display performance data, such as the number of active listings and metrics for that specific area.

Step 4: View performance metrics
With your custom region selected, click the black arrow on the left side of the screen to dive into performance data for that area.
For example, in the Doolie region, lake properties average $132,000 in revenue with a 50% occupancy rate and an ADR of $872.

If you want even more granular data, you can use AirDNA’s filters to narrow down listings by property type, bedroom count, review score, and more. This enables you to tailor your analysis to specific investment goals.

Step 5: Save and compare custom regions
Once you’ve pulled performance metrics for your first custom region, save it before moving on to create a second region for comparison. Click the save button on the filters toolbar, then click “Create New Saved Filter” and give your custom filter a name.

Now you’re ready to create your second region.
As an example, let’s say you’re interested in comparing your first region, Doolie, to properties west of Mayhew. Outline that area, and be sure to apply the same filters as your first region. Then, save it the same way you did the first one.

Step 6: Use Advanced Insights to compare side by side
Now that you have two custom regions, you can compare them side by side with the Advanced Insights tab, which is located on your dashboard in the horizontal bar under the Filters bar.

AirDNA’s Advanced Insights feature allows you to compare monthly performance across markets, listing attributes, property managers, and more for your custom regions, revealing patterns that could impact revenue.
Using Lake Norman as our example, you’d discover that 3-4 bedroom properties in Doolie earned 25% more than those in Mayhew in 2023 and have widened that gap in 2024.

The growing revenue gap for these custom regions is likely attributed to shifts in supply and demand in the two regions over the last year. Using historical performance data and charts available in the Advanced Insights tab, you can further analyze the underlying supply, demand, occupancy, and ADR changes that are impacting revenue. Analyzing these trends will help you make data-driven decisions about which part of the lake is likely to deliver higher returns.
Step 7: Review home values
Creating custom regions allows you to compare performance across different areas within a submarket and zero in on zones with the highest revenue potential. However, to make an informed investment, you’ll want to consider home values as well, since a property’s price impacts your overall yield.
When you create a custom region in AirDNA, the tool automatically filters properties currently for sale within that area. Navigate to the “For Sale Properties” tab to view all for-sale listings within your custom region, complete with essential metrics such as sale price, AirDNA’s revenue projections, occupancy, ADR, and yield for each property.

For a more tailored search, use the “For Sale” filter to narrow listings by property type, price range, bedroom and bathroom count, square footage, time on the market, and any short-term rental zoning restrictions. This filter helps you identify the right lake property that aligns with both your budget and yield goals, allowing you to make a confident, data-backed decision.

Add a minimum yield in the same tab to hide properties that are unlikely to reach your target return, which makes it faster to see which lake homes for sale can cover their costs.

Frequently Asked Questions About Buying a Lake House
What is the best place to buy a lake house for short-term rentals?
Erie, Pennsylvania tops AirDNA’s 2026 ranking of lake markets, pairing a $232,500 median list price with $32,616 in revenue potential and an 11.2% yield. Muskegon and Otsego Lake in Michigan, Tobyhanna, Pennsylvania, and Salisbury, North Carolina round out the top five. Tobyhanna returns the highest yield of the ten at 13.8%.
Is lakefront property a good investment?
It can be. The ten lake markets in this ranking return gross yields from 9.1% to 13.8%, and lake houses draw the family and group guests who pay premium rates in season. The trade-offs are concentrated income, higher maintenance and insurance costs, and local rules that can close a market to new permits, so check regulations and seasonality before you buy.
How much does a lake house cost?
Among the ten markets in this ranking, median list prices run from $232,500 in Erie, Pennsylvania to $569,999 in Mooresville, North Carolina, on Lake Norman. Homes with direct frontage and a private dock sit at the top of each market’s range, while houses a few streets back with a lake view cost less and can return more on capital.
Where can I find inexpensive lake homes for sale?
In this ranking, the lowest median list prices are in Erie, Pennsylvania ($232,500), Otsego Lake, Michigan ($285,000), and Muskegon, Michigan ($289,900), and all three return yields above 11%. Inexpensive lake homes tend to sit in drive-to and secondary lake markets rather than marquee resort towns, and in houses a few streets back from the water. AirDNA’s for-sale listings let you set a price ceiling and a minimum yield to find cheap lake homes that can still cover their costs.
How do I buy a lake house?
Start with the market, then the house. Compare lake submarkets on revenue, occupancy, seasonality, and home values, confirm that the municipality governing the parcel still issues short-term rental permits, and then check where the house sits on the lake. Use AirDNA’s for-sale listings and revenue estimates to see what a specific property could earn, and work with a local agent who knows waterfront rules such as dock rights.
When is the best time to buy a lake house?
Late fall and winter are often the best time to buy, because demand is lower and sellers may be more willing to negotiate. In high-demand summer markets, spring and early summer bring more inventory. Check the market’s seasonality first: in Manistee, 52% of booked nights fall in June through August, while in Gainesville the share is 25%.
ARTICLE SUMMARY
AirDNA ranked lake submarkets on demand, revenue growth, and gross yield on homes for sale, then removed markets closed to new permits. Here are the 10 best places to buy a lake house for short-term rentals in 2026, from Erie, Pennsylvania to Manistee, Michigan.

Camilo Schmid Rivas
Senior Research Analyst
Camilo Schmid Rivas is a Senior Research Analyst at AirDNA who brings a uniquely well-rounded perspective to short-term rental analytics. With a background that spans investment, real estate, and business analysis—including roles at Stayery and Sollers Consulting—Camilo has worn many analyst hats, each sharpening his ability to turn complex data into clear, actionable insights. A graduate of École hôtelière de Lausanne, he now channels his multidisciplinary expertise into uncovering trends that drive smarter STR decisions. In his free time, he enjoys playing tennis or scuba diving in or around Barcelona.
Get started with AirDNA today.
Powerful, easy-to-use tools that help hosts and investors succeed in the short-term rental market.
Try for free

